Should Artists Stop Paying for Instagram Ads? A Clear, Honest Breakdown

A simple and realistic explanation of why Meta Ads almost never reach collectors, why artists keep losing money on boosts, and what actually works instead.

Let’s be real. Half of the artists we talk to are quietly pouring 20 to 100 euros a month into Meta Ads hoping a collector somewhere will magically see their post and decide to buy a painting.

Instead, they get likes from other artists, friends, and people who are also posting open studios or new works.

It is like paying for a billboard and placing it inside your own living room.

Only your friends see it. And your cat.

Submit Your Work for Editorial Feature - Catapult

Ask Kurt by Catapult. A curated path into our circle for contemporary artists. Real introductions. Cultural relevance. Long-term presence includes social media cover.

Catapult - The New Munchies Art Club | Critical CuratorsDominique Catherina Foertig

Here is the truth in three simple parts.

1. WHAT IS HAPPENING

You are reaching other artists, not collectors

Instagram categorizes you based on your behavior.
If you engage with art accounts, Instagram thinks you want more art accounts. So your ads land in the feeds of:

• artists
• designers
• students
• people who are browsing for inspiration

Not collectors, galleries or curators.
This is not your mistake. It is the logic of the platform.

“Instagram is the wrong street for most conceptual artists, no matter how good the work is.”

Your small boosts do not give the algorithm enough information

A budget of 20 or 40 euros does not give Instagram enough data to understand who you want to reach.

Professional campaigns cost 1,000 to 1,500 euros per month so the system can learn.

11 Art Platforms Artists Should Know in 2025!

Discover 11 curated art platforms where artists can submit their work, get featured, and be seen by curators, collectors, and real art audiences. From Artviewer to Munchies Art Club, here’s who’s still shaping what visibility means in 2025.

Catapult - The New Munchies Art Club | Critical CuratorsDominique Catherina Foertig

Your 40 euro boost is simply too small.

Instagram shrugs and shows it to people who look like your current followers, which means more artists.

Instagram is window shopping

People stop by, look, like, maybe share, but they rarely buy.
And Instagram decides who walks past your window.
For most conceptual or niche artists, it is the wrong street.

2. WHY IT HAPPENS

Instagram is built for products, not for art

Meta Ads work best for quick and impulsive purchases, for example skincare or sneakers.

Art requires:

• context
• trust
• time
• conversation

Why Are You on Instagram as an Artist? An Honest, Realistic Look for Artists!

Instagram is a $71 billion ad machine that doesn’t owe you anything. You’re creating free content for Meta’s shareholders while calling it your ‘art career.’ Here’s what nobody tells you: most artists on Instagram will never make a living from it. But let’s be honest about why.

Catapult - The New Munchies Art Club | Critical CuratorsErnst Koslitsch

Meta Ads require:

• speed
• mass appeal
• instant desire

The systems do not fit together.

Collectors do not shop for art this way

Collectors and curators discover artists through:

• openings
• galleries
• advisors
• newsletters
• fairs
• curatorial writing

Not through a 20 euro boost.

The algorithm rewards entertainment

Bright, fast, playful, bold content wins.
Quiet, conceptual, slow content disappears.
Not because it is bad, but because it does not fit the entertainment model.

Niche art creates too little data

If your audience is small or highly specialized, Meta cannot gather enough signals.
So it pushes your ad back into the same pool of artists again and again.

3. WHAT YOU CAN DO ABOUT IT

If your art is entertainment friendly

Focus on organic growth, not ads.

Useful steps:

• consistent posting ( 2-3/week - Same Day - Same hour)
• choosing the hour when most followers are online (Your Analytics in the App)
• Carousel Posts Currently - 5 slides mix it with short videos
• studio clips (Stop Time)
• process videos (Stop Time)
• material close ups

This type of work can succeed because the content is the window display.

If your art is serious, slow, or conceptual

Stop fighting the algorithm.
Your collectors are not on Instagram trying to buy art.
They are moving inside the real art ecosystem.

Invest here instead:

✔ Curatorial features (180 to 320 euros)
Permanent, indexed, and reaching actual art audiences.

Gallery Partnerships with Munchies Art Club - Not a Shoutout, a Strategy

Media partnership for galleries. European curators creating long-term, searchable visibility beyond the feed. No noise, just substance.

Catapult - The New Munchies Art Club | Critical CuratorsDominique Catherina Foertig

✔ Gallery relationships
Trust grows slowly and matters the most.

✔ Your own community !!!!
Ten true fans are worth more than ten thousand passive followers.

Ask the right question

It is not:
“How do I fix my Meta Ads”

It is:
“Should I be using Meta Ads at all”

For most serious artists, the answer is no.

The final truth

You are not failing. You are trying to sell a violin inside a gym.

The audience and the system are not aligned.

Save your money.

Find the street where your collectors actually walk.
Build relationships in the world where art is truly discovered.

If you want weekly honest guidance without illusions, subscribe to Catapult.